Skip to main content

Water for Elephants - A Novel

Set in the middle of the Great Depression, Jacob is a university student studying to become a veterinarian to work alongside his father at his animal hospital.  During his class, the Dean of Students tells him that both of his parents were killed in an automobile accident.  Through a talk with his father’s lawyer, the animal hospital and home will be sold to the bank to cover their debt.  Jacob becomes closed off from everything and everyone and soon finds himself jumping on a moving train filled with circus performers for the Benzini Brothers Most Spectacular Show on Earth.  He talks his way into the circus as a veterinarian and becomes immediately attracted to the owner’s wife, Marlena.  And this is where the fun really begins.
One thing the author does well is the creation of August.  The reader knows from the start that there is something not right with August and so does everyone else in the circus.  It isn’t talked about nor is it confronted.  Only about ¾ of the way through the book does anyone get an idea of what he is going through – he has paranoid schizophrenia.  Today, that is not something you see or hear of very often but it was even more remote back in the 20’s when the science and technology was nothing like it is today – and the only thing people did to those unfortunate souls was to lobotomize them.  I liked reading about August – how he went from one person to the next in a matter of seconds; how he really didn’t mean to do those things but he couldn’t explain them; and how Marlena would stick with him no matter what he did to her. 
However, besides August and the general story line, there was not a lot about this book that caught me. I expected it to grab me and not let go but the only reason why I wanted to finish the book was to see if the old Jacob died at the end.
It was very dark – not in the supernatural sense but in the human sense, meaning it was the middle of the great depression.   In that time, everyone was out for themselves and out for blood if anyone got in their way of living.  Everything was scarce – food, water, work and companionship.  Everything was first come, first serve.  It is a little comical that I find this dark and disturbing more than books like Twilight, Robopocalypse and The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo.  One reason could be that this actually happened.  To read a semi non-fiction novel is sometimes harder because you aren’t taken away from your world. Rather you are thrust right back into a time when things were dire and gruesome – a place we hope we never get to again.  People read to be taken away on a grand adventure – this is not one of those.  We want to forget about our problems for an hour or two and just sink into our imaginations.
One other thing I did enjoy about the book was it went back and forth between the flashbacks and the present time.  I like how the author merged and connected the two so seamlessly that at times, I didn’t know if it was the past or the present I was reading.
Everyone that I know who has read the book swears by it and say it is a great book. I think it is a good book, not great.   After thinking about it for a week, I came to that conclusion because I couldn’t remember every bit about the book – only the high energy things such as the beginning scene and the fight and aftermath between Jacob and August.
My rating is 3 out of 5.  I am going to forget about this book in a few months and even though I will be glad I read it (mainly because most of my friends have read it) it won’t be a book that I will want to go back and re-read. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Last Song

Before I begin this review, I must put a disclaimer. The only way I got through this movie was to look past Miley Cyrus as the lead. With that said, so starts my review. With imagination running out in Hollywood, producers have to look to other forms of entertainment for inspiration. Nicholas Sparks books have always been a very good place with hit movies such as A Walk to Remember, Message in a Bottle, and The Notebook. In 2010, Hollywood made 2 of his books into movies - Dear John and The Last Song starring Miley Cyrus and Greg Kinnear. Before seeing this movie, I made it a point to read  the book so I could compare the two mediums. This story wasn't a typical Sparks novel in the sense of about finding your true love. This is a story about the dysfunctional yet oddly functional relationship between an 18-year old teenage and her estranged father. Roni and her 10 year old brother come to live at their father's house in South Carolina, on the water, for the summer much to ...

"For a Few to be Immortal, Many Must Die" - In Time

It is an interesting topic – living forever.   We all have said at one point or another we want the fountain of youth to bless us with eternal beauty and life.   But what would living forever mean? You would see history happen right before your eyes – and see it written in history books for children to read during school.   If you had been living forever, you could have seen the curse start for the Red Sox in 1918 and then get broken in 2004.   And again in 2007.   But what it would it mean?   By living forever, you don’t like a day in your life. If you live forever, what makes tomorrow so special.   The people in District 12 have it better than the rich – they have to make very moment, every second count. In Time, starring Justin Timberlake and Amanda Seyfried, is set in 2161 where a genetic alteration has allowed humanity to stop aging past age 25.   But people are required to earn more time in order to stay alive past age 25 or their ...

Don't Lose the Magic: Shadowhunters Season 1

The Shadowhunter world is powerful. Not because of magic, steles, demons, or potions but of the emotions tied to every single character.  Cassandra Clare wielded such heartening characters in her books that bringing the world to the big and little screen seemed almost too much.  When the movie came out, it didn’t live up to the hype of many dedicated fans. Now with the show having gone through its 1st season (and the 2nd season on the horizon) the question is the same: can the producers of the show keep Clare’s world in tact and please everyone?  That is a resounding no. When the news first broke that The Mortal Instrument books series would be turned into a television show I was optimistic.  The feature film had a lot of buildup and hype. Unfortunately it did not live up to the majority’s expectations and fell flat when it was released.  I enjoyed it from a movie and entertainment viewpoint but when comparing it to the book it left something to be desired...